Dynamic quotes 

MarketScreener Homepage  >  Equities  >  Toronto Stock Exchange  >  Canadian Tire Corporation Limited    CTC.A   CA1366812024


News SummaryMost relevantAll newsOfficial PublicationsSector newsAnalyst Recommendations

Canadian Tire : Activists should be allowed to speak on behalf of animals in court, lawyer argues

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
07/28/2019 | 09:43am EDT

TORONTO — A retired Toronto lawyer has gone to court in a bid to secure the right for advocates to speak up on behalf of animals in legal settings.

The case began earlier this year when Sandra Schnurr filed a notice of application against five retail giants selling glue traps, or devices commonly used to catch rodents.

Schnurr argued that the traps subject mice and rats to agonizing, prolonged deaths and filed an application seeking to ban Canadian Tire, Walmart, Home Depot, Home Hardware and Lowe's from selling them.

The retailers, in turn, filed a motion to dismiss Schnurr's complaint on the grounds that she did not have standing to bring such a matter before the courts.

But Schnurr argued that the rules surrounding who has the right to speak on various legal issues have been relaxing and animal rights advocates should be permitted a voice in Canada's courtrooms.

The issue of standing was argued before Ontario Superior Court Justice Lorne Sossin last week and should be decided in the coming months.

Schnurr said questions around standing need to be resolved before her original notice about glue traps can proceed. If standing is granted, she said the case will have struck a blow for animal rights regardless of the outcome of the original complaint.

"If we succeed at this stage, even if we ultimately lose on the glue trap issue, the fact that we will have succeeded in getting public interest standing to speak for animals would be huge," Schnurr said in a telephone interview.

Lawyers representing the retailers did not respond to a request for comment, though their objections to Schnurr's case are outlined in a factum brought before the court.

In addition to arguing Schnurr's motion represents an "abuse of process" that should be dismissed out of hand, the retailers' factum suggests Schnurr and the advocacy group she founded do not have enough at stake to merit a say on the issue.

The factum said Schnurr, founder of a group known as Canadians for Animal Protection, has not suffered any direct wrong from the sale of glue traps and should therefore not be granted standing.

The retailers also state that members of the public did not have the right to try to enforce criminal law, arguing such matters are the exclusive purview of an attorney general and citing past case law to support their position.

But Schnurr argued more recent cases suggest that position may be relaxing and courts are willing to take a broader view of public interest standing.

Schnurr particularly referenced a September 2012Supreme Court of Canada decision that granted standing to a group of advocates representing sex workers in Vancouver's Downtown East Side.

The federal government had argued the group and a previous sex worker named in the case had no standing to challenge the country's prostitution laws, since they were not facing charges under those laws themselves. The Supreme Court unanimously rejected that argument and granted them legal standing.

Schnurr said the court should take a similar approach in Ontario by granting standing to those wishing to speak up on behalf of those who cannot represent themselves.

"Obviously the court is unable to obtain the point of view of those most directly affected in the instant case, for the self-evident reason that rats and mice...cannot come to court and speak for themselves," she said. "The applicants, who are dedicated to advocating for these voiceless creatures, are the next best choice."

Schnurr said those seeking public interest standing must meet three criteria by demonstrating they're raising a genuine issue of justice, have a real stake or interest in the subject, and using court resources properly by raising an issue that can be reasonably and effectively addressed in that setting. Schnurr's factum said animal rights advocates meet all three criteria.

Sossin has reserved his decision in the case, though no date has yet been set.

© 2019 The Canadian Press. All rights reserved., source Canadian Press DataFile

share with twitter share with LinkedIn share with facebook
share via e-mail
09:43aCANADIAN TIRE : Activists should be allowed to speak on behalf of animals in cou..
07/25CANADIAN TIRE : Media Advisory - Canadian Tire Corporation Second Quarter 2019 R..
07/24CANADIAN TIRE : Indigenous man reaches deal after being thrown out of Canadian T..
07/11CANADIAN TIRE : Julien Caine drops new single with Kid Ink and Sethii Shmactt af..
06/27CANADIAN TIRE : Saskatoon man buys canoe with briefcase full of Canadian Tire ca..
06/21CANADIAN TIRE : TC Transcontinental Packaging Steals the Show for Sustainable Pa..
05/24CANADIAN TIRE : Announces Strategic Partnership with Myant Inc. to Bring Smart T..
05/09CANADIAN TIRE : Announces Election of Directors
05/09CANADIAN TIRE : profit misses on lower products shipment
05/09CANADIAN TIRE : reports Q1 profit down from year ago, revenue gains ground
More news
Financials (CAD)
Sales 2019 14 672 M
EBIT 2019 1 505 M
Net income 2019 789 M
Debt 2019 4 990 M
Yield 2019 2,87%
P/E ratio 2019 11,4x
P/E ratio 2020 10,5x
EV / Sales2019 0,97x
EV / Sales2020 0,95x
Capitalization 9 212 M
Duration : Period :
Canadian Tire Corporation Limited Technical Analysis Chart | MarketScreener
Full-screen chart
Technical analysis trends CANADIAN TIRE CORPORATION
Short TermMid-TermLong Term
Income Statement Evolution
Mean consensus OUTPERFORM
Number of Analysts 12
Average target price 169,58  CAD
Last Close Price 145,71  CAD
Spread / Highest target 35,2%
Spread / Average Target 16,4%
Spread / Lowest Target -5,98%
EPS Revisions
Stephen G. Wetmore President, Chief Executive Officer & Director
Maureen Joanne Sabia Non-Executive Chairman
Dean C. McCann Chief Financial Officer & Executive Vice President
Owen G. Billes Non-Independent Director
Timothy Robert Price Independent Director
Sector and Competitors
1st jan.Capitalization (M$)
S.A.C.I. FALABELLA--.--%15 818
MACY'S-23.20%7 064
NORDSTROM-34.97%4 717